Begin typing your search above and press return to search. Press Esc to cancel.

The Galen Healthcare Solutions Blog

The Galen Healthcare Solutions Blog

Primary Navigation

  • Please select a menu in this location
Legacy EHR Retirement & Archival: Medical Professional Liability Claims, Risks, EHR e-Discovery & Metadata
Home
Archival
Audit
Data Archival

Legacy EHR Retirement & Archival: Medical Professional Liability Claims, Risks, EHR e-Discovery & Metadata


By
Justin Campbell
.
Published on October 25, 2018. 0

In an EHR market rife with consolidation and replacement, healthcare delivery organizations (HDOs) have adopted healthcare data archival solutions to retire legacy systems. Archival allows for reduced costs (legacy system licensing, system support & maintenance), mitigation of risks (antiquated technology and security), and preservation of access. However, while substantial benefits may be achieved through legacy system retirement and archival, additional risks may be introduced due to missed data sets including contextual audit trails, referenced data in ancillary systems, data change & version history, and infrequently used, invisible fields or other metadata. This was recently addressed in a post by John Lynn, of Healthcare Scene, detailing the problematic nature of of EHR replacement driving lost data.

Attorneys and, in turn, judges have been grappling with the terms metadata and audit trails as EHRs and, more generally, electronically stored information, have become the subject of increased discovery requests and legal motions. The Doctors Company, the nation’s largest physician owned medical malpractice insurer, published a study in October of 2017, highlighting the rise of EHR-related malpractice suits. The study revealed that claims in which EHRs are a factor grew from just 2 in 2007 through 2019 to 161 from 2011 through December 2016. This is directly material to clinical data archival, as it is expected that the archival solution stores the same data as the legacy EHR it replaced.

Electronic Discovery, or e-Discovery, is the modern version of the traditional pre-trial process of an attorney requesting that the opposing party turn over copies of documents in hopes of finding valuable evidence. The scope of the searches related to e-discovery includes nearly anything electronic. Legacy or antiquated EHRs, and consequently the archival systems that replace them, are attractive targets for e-discovery because they contain so much potentially useful information, including patient demographics, progress notes, problems, medications, vital signs, past medical history, immunizations, laboratory data, and radiology reports. The danger is that archival systems used to persist this data in accordance with state requirements are not capturing all of the data needed to give a complete view of the circumstances surrounding patient care.

Healthcare delivery organizations are required to retain data for nearly a decade or more past the date of service and the costs of producing record for e-Discovery typically average $20K per gigabyte. In eDiscovery, the most frequently asked questions pertain to alerts (bypassed?), notes (who wrote it? who has reviewed it? when was it written? when was it signed? was it changed?), medication ordering, and lab review.

Groundbreaking cases include Griffith v Aultman Hospital, on March 23, 2016, where the Ohio Supreme Court deemed that the patient’s medical record is not limited to data in the medical records department. This pertained to cardiac strips but opens the door to the EHR. In addition, State laws now frequently addresses issues relating to eDiscovery: VA 32.1-127.1:03: “Health record” means any written, printed or electronically recorded material maintained by a health care entity in the course of providing health services to an individual concerning the individual and the services provided. Embedded metadata, such as notes revisions and versioning are generally hidden, but an integral part of electronic stored information, such as “track changes” or “comments.”

Healthcare delivery organizations have historically designated their HIM departments as the official “custodians of medical records.” Most HIM departments process and respond to subpoenas in state court, where the majority of medical-malpractice litigation occurs. As such, it is critical to incorporate consideration of commonly missed data sets into a healthcare delivery organization’s e-Discovery response approach and information governance program.

Download our free EHR Archival Strategy whitepaper to further understand how to address commonly missed data sets, the various approaches to extraction transformation & storage of the contents of clinical systems, and evaluation archival strategies including raw data backups, extracted schema stores, modeled document, and non-discrete indexed document.

Facebook Twitter Email

Share this:

  • Share
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
Categories ArchivalAuditData Archival
Tags EHR e-DiscoveryEHR metadataHealthcare Data Archivallegacy application retirementLegacy EHR

0 likes
avatar

Author

Justin Campbell

Justin joined Galen in 2008 and is responsible for driving marketing and brand strategy. Justin started at Galen as a Technical Consultant, enabling Galen’s clients in the integration and optimization within their clinical and administrative systems portfolio. Previous to his current role, Justin led Galen’s Technical Services team, responsible for leading its innovation, partnerships, growth and success. Justin actively contributes to company initiatives including strategy, sales, marketing, business development and services & solutions development. Prior to joining Galen, Justin served as the IT Director for a long-term care pharmacy, leading a paperless initiative, the migration of the Pharmacy Information System (PIS) from a legacy platform, and the integration of the PIS to the pharmacy’s packaging system. Justin also served as a Microprocessor and RF/Mixed Signal Test Engineer at IBM, participating in the development of a custom FPGA jitter measurement solution used in a production testing environment. Justin holds a M.S. in CIS from Boston University and a M.S. in Computer Engineering & B.S. in Electrical Engineering from the University of Vermont.

  • Website

+ There are no comments

Add yours

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Galen Healthcare Solutions

Tags

#IAmGalen Allscripts Allscripts Consultants Allscripts Touchworks EHR CHIME CIO CIO Interview ConnectR Coronavirus Custom Reports Database Data Conversion data migration EHR EHR Conversion EHR Data Conversion EHR Implementation Electronic Health Record Enterprise EHR Epic Extensibility Galen Webcast Series Healthcare IT Health Information Exchange HealthIT CIO Interview HIE HIPAA HL7 ICD-10 Integration Interfaces Interoperability Meaningful Use MEDITECH Optimization Patient Engagement Population Health Management Reporting Successful EHR Implementation Technical TeleHealth This Week in Health IT TouchWorks Training Value Based Care VitalCenter

Recent Posts

  • RLDatix Acquires Galen Healthcare Solutions
  • Galen Healthcare Solutions Celebrates International Women’s Day
  • Take Charge of Your Application Portfolio
  • eClinicalWorks Data Extract Considerations
  • #IAmGalen: Michael Buhman, Technical Consultant

Recent Comments

Lisa Gresko on How to Migrate Midmark EKGs to a New EHR

We are also having request from users to get the MidMark IQManager test results which are on the .car files into a format which is […]

Barry Chamberland on How to Migrate Midmark EKGs to a New EHR

Thanks Asher for you input and sorry all that I have not responded to yet. Yes its true that we can't technically "share" the […]

Asher Ekstein on How to Migrate Midmark EKGs to a New EHR

Hi, To everyone commenting here, I was never sent the script, I was told that it was private company resources that couldn't be shared, and […]

Christian Nicolas on How to Migrate Midmark EKGs to a New EHR

Hi Barry, We also need the same assistance with our Midmark files. We actually have a custom script similar to what you have but the issue […]

Teresa Edwards on How to Migrate Midmark EKGs to a New EHR

Barry, I'm guessing that instead of "share the script", the Galen team will offer to sell the service. However, If you are […]

Archives

2019 © Galen Healthcare Solutions